[MPlayer-advusers] incoming review april 2008

[Roberto Togni]

On Sun, 13 Apr 2008 20:19:26 -0400
Compn <tempn at twmi.rr.com> wrote:

note: not all list processed yet. Comments welcome on unprocessed
entries.

We really need to find a way to let people that use a sample to fix a
bug to report about the fate of the file (keep or delete).


> ====move to samples====
> all h264/1080 samples move to h264 for fixing/testing/fate
> 
if somebody who knows h264 can tell apart the good files from the
broken ones please report, else i'll move everything to h264 samples.

> /image-samples/
> /bmp/
> move to bmp or image-samples
done. the image-samples dir contains also some txt describing the files

> 
> ------
> /new format .oxm/
> open game format with vorbis audio
> 
moved to game-formats/dig mc dug

> lain.str
> psx sample 
> 
moved

> advertise30M.pss
> ps2 sample
> 
moved

> /myst-adpcm3/
> game-formats-*
> decompress
> and move these to game-formats for mike
done. game-formats-ea.tar.bz2 is broken and was deleted. the
game-formats-ea-retry.tar.bz2 is ok and seem to have the same content
but is missing the ea-wve-uv2 directory (broken in the original file).


list of game-formats-ea-retry.tar.bz2
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-cmv/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-cmv/readme-cmv.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-cmv/TITLE.CMV
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mad/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mad/readme-mad.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mad/THX_logo.mad
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mp3/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mp3/readme-mp3.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mp3/xsong1.asf
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mpc/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mpc/EAL_PORP.MPC
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mpc/PSA.mpc
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-mpc/readme-mpc.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-tgq-uv/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-tgq-uv/readme-uv.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-tgq-uv/TITLEAV_truncated.UV
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-vp6/
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-vp6/nbalive07_english_ntsc_truncated.vp6
game-formats-ea-retry/ea-vp6/readme-vp6.txt
game-formats-ea-retry/notes.txt

the file also suggest these renames in a readme file

electronic arts samples
=======================
readme file is included in each subdir

please rename existing dirs to add clarity:
	samples/game-formats/tgv -> ea-tgv
	samples/game-formats/tgq -> ea-tgq-uv
	samples/game-formats/wve -> ea-wve
	samples/game-formats/dct-mad -> ea-dct (*.dct files)
	samples/game-formats/dct-mad -> ea-mad (*.mad files)

I'll let Mike decide on them.


> ----
> 
> test1.mpg
> move to subcc sample, check why both cc streams are playing at once.
moved to MPEG2/subcc

> 
> MPlayerRC1PlaybackCrash_david at pastornet.net.au.mov
> crash in mplayer, none in ffmpeg
> 
> ogg-audio.mov
> quicktime cant play it without some component
> 
> 20061209ranbat_3rd-part.wmv
> j-frame sample
moved

> 
> /corepng/
> corepng codec and sourcecode
> 
> /Apple_ProRes_422/
> fourcc: apch , format mov
The txt says it's requested by Mike. Mike, can you have a look and
report if the full 150MB sample is needed or if the cut one is enough?

> 
> asian-commercials-are-weird.flv
> http://bugzilla.mplayerhq.hu/show_bug.cgi?id=1028
> 
moved to FLV

> Blackmagic_codecs.conf
> BMDCodecLib.dll
> move to samples/drivers
ok

> 
> flash_adpcm_testfiles
> flash_flv_adpcm_testfiles
> move to flash samples
> 
moved to SWF and FLV

> larger_than_64k_flac_metadata
> move to flac
done

> 
> /liquidaudio/
> move to samples
is it lossy or lossless?

> 
> luckynight.aif
> move to lossless audio samples
i think is ima4 so not lossless. moved to AIFF

> 
> lucy_letters_to_satan_2007.mov
> http://roundup.mplayerhq.hu/roundup/ffmpeg/issue405
moved to svq3

> 
> /Quicktime/
> bunch of quicktime components
> move to samples if useful
MacOSX stuff, somebody please comment. what are they? codecs? warez?

> 
> 
> 
> ====get status/report from ffmpeg====
> all ffmpeg* files and directories

Somebody please comment. is there anybody from ffmpeg on this list?

> 
> /asli/
> ffmpeg assertion sample
> 
> ABC_SD.dvr-ms
> reported to ffmpeg-devel
> 
> /bug_asf_malloc/
> bunch of errors
> 
> BrianCox.mov 
> move to samples
> ffdv problem
> 
> GMCMidiaASX.mov
> wmv in mov
> [mov,mp4,m4a,3gp,3g2,mj2 @ 0x65eb20]could not determine chunk size, report problem
> 
> H263_ALAC_24bits.mov
> ALAC_24bits2.mov
> [alac @ 0x6109f0]FIXME: unimplemented sample size 24
moved to A-codec/lossless/alac

> 
> Po-Slow_Death_64K.mov
> utils.c:639: failed assertion `pkt->duration && !st->cur_dts'
> 
> mp4box_frag.mp4
> created with mp4box, broken file?
> ask expert
> 
> haruhi.mkv
> http://article.gmane.org/gmane.comp.video.mplayer.devel/48234
> 
> /jason.askew/
> reported on ffmpeg-user
> 
> /rajiv/
> pixel format conversion not handled
> 
> /SDIsample/
> sdi sample for ffmpeg
> 
> /tooSmall/
> still a problem ?
> 
> framerate_problem_full.wmv
> packetsize problems, seek problems too
> 
> /mjpeg/
> [mjpeg @ 0x840fbc0]Subsampling in JPEG-LS
> sample
moved to V-codcs/MJPEGs/JPEG-LS

> 
> mov00003.mqv
> audio problem in ffmpeg/demuxer lavf
> works in quicktime
> 
> orenh/
> h263 video with incorrect playback res
moved to mov/h263-badsize

> 
> 
> 
> 
> ========delete======
> At_the_End_high.mov
> At_the_End_high.mov.txt
> At_the_End_high.mov.READFIRST.txt
> delete, incomplete file
ok

> 
> epk_violator320.mov
> blue tint observed in quicktime and mplayer, pebcak
> delete
> 
ok

> partyscool.ogg 
> broken file
> delete
ok

> 
> crashes-linux_windows-swscaler-bug.mp4
> doesnt crash on mac or windows for me.
> delete
ok

> 
> DGray-man_-_01_168_230.mp4
> mplayer demuxer bug, works in svn
> delete
> 
> Soukou_no_Strain_06_\[WinD]\(h264\)\[514C204C].mp4
> mplayer demuxer bug, works in svn
> delete
> 
> [Order]_Tengen_Toppa_Gurren_Lagann_-_01_[83DAF271].mp4
> mplayer demuxer bug, works in svn
> delete
> 
> claymore01_small.mp4
> mplayer demuxer bug, works in svn
> delete

do we need any of these files? do they have some important feature of
mp4 file?

> 
> bug_870_sample.mp4
> fixed in svn
> delete
worth keeping?

> 
> macisgay.mpg
> broken file
> delete
ok

> 
> ce31b291aaa34304e86fca30a2b330b1.wmv
> works for me
> delete
ok

> 
> broken_wma/
> See: http://lists.mplayerhq.hu/pipermail/ffmpeg-devel/2007-April/026918.html
> delete if uneeded?
deleted. was user error not broken file

> 
> asf_no_playback.asf
> worksforme
> delete
ok

> 
> XMAS_VIDEO_Oxygene_30th_Anniversary.mov
> works in svn
> http://lists.mplayerhq.hu/pipermail/mplayer-dev-eng/2007-December/055810.html
> delete
ok (file was 150MB)

> 
> doom9.avi
> worksforme
> delete
ok

> 
> bug.avi 
> worksforme
> delete
ok

> 
> /ktnc/
> worksforme
> delete
ok

> 
> /m2v/
> seems correct fps in svn ffmpeg
> delete
> 
> ps2_interdite.mpg
> fixed in svn ffmpeg
> delete
> 
> /no_codec_param/
> works in svn ffmpeg
> delete
> 
> 
> 
> 
> ----------ping bcoudurier---------
> newyearsvidcast.mp4
> cat NewYearsVidCast.txt
> This is a reference MOV file that plays correctly on iPod 5G, requested by bcoudurier, uploaded by cartman
> 
> 
> ---------ping rathann/reimar----------
> [AonE_-_Conclave]_Devil_May_Cry_-_01_[x264][1280x720][AAC_5.1][E1F8CD70].mp4
> still a problem in svn ?
> ping rathann
> 
> 16grey.mov
> 256grey.mov
> similar to raw yuv2 in mov, ping reimar
> 
> 
> ---------------ping nico------------
> mad.mpg 
> can ts demuxer have a default fps ?
> 
> all mpeg, ts, m2ts,  ms-dvr, vob, files
> please review :)
> 
> 
> 
> ----------------ping rxt----------------
> 08_lect_13.rm
> video streams not found

new kind of multirate real file. i have more samples. moved to samples.
File is huge (140MB), probably can't be cut. smaller samples are
welcome.


Ciao,
 Roberto

-- 
Better is the enemy of good enough.