On Sun, Feb 16, 2003 at 03:07:48PM -0600, mp_rohar@cafe.t-l-a.com wrote:

[Automatic answer: RTFM (read DOCS, FAQ), also read DOCS/bugreports.html] I have one slower machine with a dvd, and I am attempting to rip a ntsc dvd with mencoder, and then use a faster system to encode it.

I did this on the dvd machine:

mencoder -dvd 1 -oac copy -ovc copy -o out.avi

and then tried encoding on another machine with:

mencoder out.avi -oac copy -ovc lavc -lavcopts vcodec=mpeg4:vpass=1:vbitrate=2000:vhq -o movie.avi

Both in the initial rip and the encode, I get alot of "duplicate 1 frame(s)" messages and the resulting video isn't laggie, but it appears like it is only about 15-20 fps video. The audio is synced perfectly, but it seems like there are missing frames and then there are duplicates filling in the sync, giving an output that looks like 15-20fps video.

I tried the same idea with mplayer -dumpstream, and although I get alot of "1 duplicate frame(s)" messages during the encoding step, the video appears better.

Is there something wrong with my original procedure of "-oac copy -ovc copy" to rip a dvd raw? Should I just use the -dumpstream instead? or should I just shut up and buy a dvd player for my other system? :)

Yes, you should most definitely use -dumpstream. And yes, there is something wrong with your procedure. The broken telecine nonsense they use in NTSC DVDs can't be stored well in AVI files. You could try with -ofps 23.976, but again, it's better to just use -dumpstream to leave it as a .vob file. Rich