On Wed, Feb 23, 2005 at 03:55:11PM -0800, Trent Piepho wrote:
On Wed, 23 Feb 2005, D Richard Felker III wrote:
ok, at some point someone should make a guide for how to encode (compliant) vcd/svcd/dvd with mencoder's new mpeg muxer. a few questions i have right away:
- is there any way to make the muxer handle soft telecine for you
- what encoder options do you use to make compliant mpeg1/2 video for vcd/svcd/dvd? so far i've had luck, but the players i've tested
I tried to use mencoder and lavc to create (X)SVCDs that I could play on my DVD player. I normally use mpeg2enc from the mjpegtools package, which works, but lavc is faster. I used the mplex program from mjegtools to work around mencoder's broken mpeg muxer. There were still two problems that kept it from working.
well, the mpeg muxer is no longer broken -- that's the point.
The first is that I couldn't figure out a way to get soft-telecin, and trying to encode 24fps on NTSC without soft-telecin is pointless.
for vcd it's fine to just use 23.976 fps mode. i know this isn't allowed on dvd (very stupid!!!) but i'm not sure about svcd..? if this is an issue, it seems like it should be easy to fix. either add a hack in the mpeg muxer to do the telecine flags, or a hack in ve_lavc to add them there...
The second is that the rate control, specifically vrc_maxrate, doesn't appear to work. No matter what rate control options I used, the encoding would have peak bitrates much too high for my DVD player to play from CD-RW media.
it works as long as you set the vbv buffer size (vrc_buf_size) correctly. at least it worked for me making a vcd yesterday... rich