Dnia czwartek, 4 maja 2006 19:42, Uoti Urpala napisaĆ:
On Thu, 2006-05-04 at 18:24 +0200, David Lamparter wrote:
Evgeniy Stepanov wrote:
Here is an attempt to add ASS rendering capability to mplayer. It is designed as a filter and supports a large part of ASS so-called specification.
Congratulations for starting the 3rd independent open source SSA/ASS renderer project. And sorry for being slightly pissed by this.
If the effort, instead of being splitted to 3 projects, would have gone into one project, we'd by now have a full-fledged ASS renderer, and not three equally unfinished slowly-if-at-all progressing projects.
While not complete, I think his renderer is already pretty good, and it's unfair to characterize it as an "equally unfinished slowly-if-at-all progressing project". He's fixed problems found in it pretty quickly, and I'd expect it to be added to MPlayer in the near future. If you think the other projects might be better candidates for MPlayer SSA/ASS subtitle rendering, you should provide arguments for that; however based on the asa website you mentioned that project does not look like a viable candidate at the moment.
I agree, watching movie with this filter I can't say, what subtitles is called "soft" and what are called "hard". It's the best implemetation that I saw working. Anyway I found unimplement? function :P It's a subtitles that are displayed as going info (like on news channel going from right to left). Currently they are boxed to the screen (don't dissapear outside screen but they are going up :/) When I found this movie, I will send screenshot and sample about it. Besides if it's "3rd independent open source SSA/ASS renderer project" then why it's first that is used in popular player?? -- Piotr Stachura