[MPlayer-advusers] old-incoming review

[Roberto Togni]

On Wed, 17 Jan 2007 16:32:27 -0500
compn <tempn at twmi.rr.com> wrote:

> here is a review of files in old-incoming.
> i skipped over some mencoder and ffmpeg bugs.
> i read the .txt files that came with these files.
> 
> i will review more files after these are moved/deleted.
> 
> 
> #############delete
> !under_checking/vp3/
> works
> delete

non-existant directrory

[...]
> !under_checking/decoding_artifacts.mpg
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/Minolta-test.mov
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/RealAudioscrambled_after_several_seconds_with
mplayer_under_realplayer8_plays_fine-fmg2.ra
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/seg11_with_mplayercvs_ok_with_mplayer090.mpg
> works
> delete 

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/unknown_aspect_ratio-seal__this_could_be_heaven_by_bvr_ben.mpg
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/underworld-audio not working.mov
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> !under_checking/wrong_image_size_and_crash.rm
> works
> delete

file not found

[...]
> buggyDMOdecoding.wmv
> iive committed patch to fix
> ffplay crashed when playing it. maybe unreproducable.
> delete

small file, moved to samples/V-codecs/WV9

[...]
> garelka.au
> fixed a while back (see bugzilla)
> works
> delete

created samples/au/ and moved file

[...]
> WMA_protected_napster.wma
> drm file
> delete

moved to A-codecs/WMA9/drm (we din't had any file with drm)

[...]
> philwo.tar.bz2
> samples work in svn.
> demuxer lavf still having trouble with matroska? 
> [matroska @ 005A7A10]Unknown entry 0xbf in cluster data
> delete if demuxer lavf mkv support is incomplete.

not deleted, anybody cares to comment?

> 
> 
> ################mplayer problem
> crashing realmedia file/
> crashes in svn at 00:08:30.
> cant verify if crash in codec or mplayer.

moved to samples/real/real-bug/sig11

> 
> 
> gittin_13.ra
> garbled audio in svn

moved to samples/real/RA/sipr, looks interesting

> 
> 
> slow_22050hz_audio_video.avi
> demuxer lavf works and reports:
> AUDIO: 44100 Hz, 2 ch, s16le, 96.0 kbit/6.80% (ratio: 12000->176400)
> mplayer avi demuxer reports 
> AUDIO: 22050 Hz, 2 ch, s16le, 416.0 kbit/58.96% (ratio: 52000->88200)

not deleted, file was created with mencoder, broken file or bug in avi
demuxer?

> 
> 
> !under_checking/ERROR - Video is just black and no sound
> still black video, with ffdv and mcdv

Comments? 4cc is CDVC file is huge (202Mb), if it's useless i don't
want to put it in samples.

> 
> 
> !under_checking/techno/
> requires -ac +ffmp3 -demuxer lavf to play correctly
> mp3lib bug ?

not deleted, will move to samples if nobody comments on it.

> 
> !under_checking/baaaaaad.avi
> still crashes in svn at same point it did in .90

not deleted. no idea about the crash, but by looking into it the file
is asf, not avi

> 
> !under_checking/Clannad.Interview.avi
> bad file? has dx50 fourcc but no video?
> delete

not deleted now. comments?

> 
> !under_checking/taktisk_udrykning_gd_forkert.mov
> mplayer cant find right colorspace?
> ffplay works
> maybe related to mjpeg playback problem in svn

moved to samples/V-codecs/MJPEGs/mjpa-b.mov/
file is mjpa

> 
> 
> ################ask nico:
> C4orig.mpg
> to-nico-dmb-stream
> AO_Nico-*
> dvbsubtest.ts
> dvb-C4menc.mpg
> dvb-C4orig.mpg
> LOSTBOYS* -broken file? encoded vob? cant get it working with vlc. pebcak?

ping nico

> ################ask sascha/diego/nico
> replay_mpeg*

ping sasha/diego/nico

> 
> ###############ask guillaume
> tivo/Lou_Dobbs_Tonight-Renamed_for_Guillaume.TiVo

what is a tivo file? mpeg2? should it go into is some subdir or should
i create a top-level TiVo dir? file is 35Mb

> 
> 
> ################ffplay problem:
> VideoCD_DAT_Sample/
> ffplay has problem.

anybody?

> 
> 
> ################ask mike melanson
> old-incoming/!under_checking/reaper-fmv/
> These files are from the PC version of the game Rollcage.
> ask mike melanson and move to samples or delete
> 
> !other/psx/
> dbz playstation iso
> delete, unless mike melanson wants to check it for in-game video.

did you cc'd mike?

> 
> 
> ################ask eugeni
> ass_encoding_sample/
> ask evengly what to do with this.folder.
> read do_not_make_these_files_public file.

ping eugeni

> 
> 
> ################move to samples
> Dual Audio WMV/
> works4me.http://bugzilla.mplayerhq.hu/show_bug.cgi?id=172
> move to samples
> 
> 
> dvcpro50_aurora.avi
> move to dvcpro50 sample if needed

moved to /V-codecs/DV50

> 
> 
> MP4_with_ttxtSUB/
> another mp4 subtitle sample
> delete or move to samples.

moved to samples/MPEG-4

> 
> 
> anonymous_was_here_with_trained_monkeys/
> Windows wma/wmv libs from Linspire 5.0
> move somewhere

we already have them, deleted

[...]
> mpeg2_demux_bug.vob
> another libmpeg2 reinit bug
> known bug, see http://bugzilla.mplayerhq.hu/show_bug.cgi?id=318
> move to samples or delete

comments?

> 
> 
> !under_checking/Qclp/
> move to samples or delete

txt says that they are from a game "Code Blue", ask mike else i'll put
them as qclp samples

> 
> !under_checking/vp6-test/
> move interesting ones to samples

great! a VP60 sample! moved. other non-vp6 files deleted

> 
> !under_checking/clip01570.KQE
> emblaze format sample
> move to samples or delete

moved

> 
> !under_checking/SSA_15subtitles.mkv
> 15 subtitle languages in mkv
> move to samples?

moved to Matroska/subtitles

All other files from the original mail have been deleted.

Ciao,
 Roberto